Discuss the nature-nurture debate in relation to the development of an individual.(M1)
Evaluate how nature and nurture may affect the physical, intellectual, emotional and social development of two stages of the development of an individual, (D1)
In this task I’m going to be discussing the nature nurture debate in relation my individual Mariah Carey based on two life stages and evaluating how nature and nurture can affect her development. I will also link this to her physical, intellectual, emotional and social development. The life stages that I will be discussing are Mariah’s childhood and adulthood.
Many philosophers believe in nature and argue that we are influenced genetically and biologically and we are born to be they way we are whilst other philosophers believe that social, economic and environmental influences and the way we are brought up is what makes us what determines how we’ll turn out
Childhood (4-9):
Physical: Mariah Carey’s physical characteristics were genetically inherited from her parents. For example her eye colour, hair colour and height were all determined by genetics . This is nature based as it is to do with genetics and biological factors. It could’ve been predicted that Mariah Carey would become a good singer before she was even born as her mother was an opera singer.
Intellectual: Mariah knew how to communicate by using words to exchange in conversation. When she was four years old she went to singing lessons and this would have helped boost her vocabulary although she wouldn’t have quite understood how ideas like numbers, mass and volume worked. Those singing lessons would’ve boosted her passion for music and singing as well. This is nurture because she wasn’t born with that knowledge and developed the ability to communicate from her environment. At school she did well in subjects such as art, music and literature.
Emotional: Mariah would have used her imagination to understand the social roles people in her play and understand a self concept. Relationships with her parents and other family members would’ve had an affect on her self confidence. She said growing up biracial was really difficult because she felt she was different and she didn’t know where she fit in. She also said she felt rejected from her maternal family. This made have a really low self esteem but music helped her overcome it. She said that at the age of four she began to sneak a radio under the covers at night to sing which helped her find peace.
Social: Mariah would have been attached to the adults that cared for her which were her mother and father until they divorced when she was three years old and her older sister moved in with him whilst her and her brother stayed with their mother. At this she was able to realise that and this could’ve also be a reason that growing up she had low self esteem issues.
Adulthood (19-65):
Intellectual: Adulthood is the stage where individuals become increasingly wise and use past experiences to resolve situations. This is nurture as past experiences have impacted Mariah in either good or bad ways and she therefore learnt from them. She would’ve been less influenced by nature as she would be making her own decisions. In her early adulthood she was working as a waitress in many restaurants, studying cosmetology and trying to work on her music career at night.
Emotional: In her early adulthood Mariah was rejected by loads of record labels whilst at the same time working many jobs and studying which could’ve affected her emotionally. After becoming extremely successful, In 2001 she was hospitalised for extreme exhaustion and physical and emotional breakdown. This would’ve been a tough time for her she would’ve had to have taken a break from her ambitions and goals to focus on her health. Adulthood is also the stage where you learn to cope with emotional attachment to a sexual partner. So this means that you have to learn not to become to self centred, defensive or isolated emotionally. These are things you learn from experience therefore being nurture. Mariah’s first marriage was in 1993 but only lasted 4 years. She then got married in 2008 but got divorced again 8 years later.
Social: Adulthood is the stage where you form sexual partnerships and do things like start a career, married or have children. Mariah gave birth to twins in 2011. Some people would say that this is nature because its what is expected of everyone. Others would say its nurture because not it doesn’t always apply to everyone. For example someone may not want to get married or have children. It depends on how the person was brought and what they believe is right for them.
References
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mariah_Carey
https://www.biography.com/people/mariah-carey-9542177